hrms vs SimplePay
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
HRMS is a comprehensive, open-source human resource management and payroll solution designed to streamline workforce operations. Built on the powerful Frappe framework, it offers modern tools for handling employee lifecycles, attendance tracking, leave management, and expense claims. The platform provides organizations with full control over their HR data through flexible deployment options, making it suitable for teams seeking a customizable and transparent alternative to traditional proprietary HR systems.
SimplePay is a cloud-based payroll software company built specifically for South African businesses. It automates PAYE, UIF, and SDL calculations, generates SARS e@syFile-ready IRP5 and IT3(a) submissions, and keeps payroll aligned with South African Department of Labour requirements. The platform also includes leave management with custom leave policies, an employee self-service portal for leave requests and banking detail changes, and mobile apps for iOS and Android. SimplePay integrates with accounting software including Xero and QuickBooks, and offers a free 30-day trial with full feature access before billing begins.
- 100% open-source and customizable
- Self-hosted deployment options for data privacy
- Comprehensive payroll and attendance features
- Active community and Frappe ecosystem support
- Built specifically for South African payroll compliance (PAYE, UIF, SDL, SARS e@syFile), reducing manual tax calculation work.
- Free 30-day trial gives full access to features before committing to a paid subscription.
- Employee self-service portal reduces HR admin burden for routine requests like leave and banking updates.
- Direct integrations with Xero and QuickBooks simplify bookkeeping handoff.
- Requires technical expertise for self-hosting and setup
- Fewer out-of-the-box third-party integrations compared to enterprise SaaS
- Documentation can be technical for non-developers
- Pricing is not published as a flat rate; the on-site pricing calculator requires interaction to see a rate, and larger accounting firms/bureaus must contact sales directly.
- Purpose-built for South African tax and labour law, so it is not a fit for payroll outside South Africa.
- Feature set is payroll and leave-focused rather than a full HR suite (no broader recruitment or performance management modules mentioned on the site).
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to hrms
View all →
Alternatives to SimplePay
View all →
AI-centric HR and payroll platform helping Indonesian businesses manage the full employee lifecycle.
Real-time expense management and credit card reconciliation via text message, built on Fyle's platform.
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataSimplePay offers ready‑to‑use, South‑Africa‑specific payroll compliance with built‑in accounting integrations, while hrms provides a free, open‑source, self‑hosted HR suite that requires technical setup.
Key differences
- •Geographic compliance: SimplePay is built for South African SARS, UIF, SDL; hrms is generic.
- •Deployment model: SimplePay is SaaS cloud; hrms is self‑hosted requiring own infrastructure.
- •Cost: SimplePay pricing not disclosed (requires quote); hrms is free open‑source.
- •Integrations: SimplePay connects directly to Xero and QuickBooks; hrms mainly integrates within the Frappe/ERPNext ecosystem.
- •Support: SimplePay offers free customer support and training; hrms relies on community forums and GitHub.
Pricing & value
hrms is listed as free, while SimplePay requires a quoted subscription price.
Ease of use / learning curve
SimplePay is a cloud SaaS with ready‑made UI; hrms needs self‑hosting and technical setup.
Features & depth
hrms covers full employee records, attendance, performance, and expense claims beyond payroll.
Integrations & ecosystem
SimplePay integrates directly with Xero and QuickBooks, key accounting platforms for many SMEs.
Support
SimplePay provides free customer support and online training; hrms only offers community forum and GitHub issues.
Security & privacy
SimplePay offers 2‑factor authentication; hrms can be self‑hosted for data control, but specifics not detailed.
Choose hrms if…
Businesses wanting a customizable, free HR suite and can manage self‑hosting and technical setup.
Choose SimplePay if…
South African SMEs needing compliant payroll and accounting integration, without technical hosting expertise.
Common questions
What is the total cost to start using each product?
SimplePay requires contacting sales for a quote; hrms is free open‑source.
Can I use SimplePay for payroll outside South Africa?
No, SimplePay is purpose‑built for South African tax and labour law compliance only.
Do I need technical staff to run hrms?
Yes, hrms must be self‑hosted and configured, which typically requires technical expertise.