The Bigs vs The Bigs 2
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
The BIGS delivers fast‑paced, arcade baseball fun, letting you blast power‑ups and turbo boosts while playing with all 30 MLB teams and their real stadiums. Modes like Rookie Challenge and Home Run Pinball add unique twists, from building a career to smashing windows in Times Square. Its split‑screen multiplayer and easy‑to‑learn controls make it perfect for casual gamers and baseball fans looking for instant excitement without deep simulation detail.
The BIGS 2 delivers fast‑paced, arcade baseball action featuring all 30 MLB teams, authentic stadiums and real player rosters. It emphasizes fun over simulation, letting players blast home runs with power‑ups and turbo boosts while enjoying split‑screen multiplayer. The Wii version adds motion‑based swinging and drumming for a more immersive experience, but the core gameplay shines on PS3, Xbox 360 and PS2.
- Fast, accessible gameplay
- All official MLB teams and rosters
- Unique modes like Home Run Pinball
- Local split‑screen multiplayer
- All MLB teams and stadiums are present
- Exciting power‑up and turbo mechanics
- Local split‑screen multiplayer
- Simple, accessible controls
- Limited depth compared to simulation titles
- Graphics are dated by modern standards
- No online multiplayer
- Arcade focus may disappoint simulation purists
- Limited online features
- Wii motion controls not available on all platforms
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to The Bigs
View all →
Alternatives to The Bigs 2
View all →
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataThe Bigs 2 updates the original with newer rosters and a higher critic score, but otherwise offers similar arcade baseball fun.
Key differences
- •Release year and roster freshness: The Bigs 2 (2009) has up‑to‑date 2009 rosters; The Bigs (2007) uses older rosters.
- •Critic scores: The Bigs 2 scored 63/100, The Bigs scored 73/100, indicating better reviews for the original.
- •Platform coverage: The Bigs lists PS3, Xbox 360, PS2; The Bigs 2 mentions Wii motion controls but no specific consoles.
- •Unique modes: The Bigs includes Rookie Challenge and Home Run Pinball; The Bigs 2 does not list these modes.
- •Price detail: The Bigs 2 MSRP is $59.99; The Bigs price not specified.
Gameplay & fun factor
Both are arcade‑style with power‑ups, turbo mode and split‑screen; no evidence one is more fun.
Platform availability
The Bigs lists PS3, Xbox 360, PS2; The Bigs 2 only mentions Wii motion controls.
Price & value
The Bigs 2 MSRP $59.99; The Bigs price not provided, so cannot determine superiority.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Both support single‑player, local multiplayer and split‑screen up to four players.
Content & replayability
The Bigs 2 has newer 2009 rosters; The Bigs uses older 2007 rosters.
Difficulty & accessibility
Both target casual gamers with simple controls; no data on difficulty differences.
Graphics & performance
The Bigs received a higher critic score (73 vs 63), suggesting better overall presentation.
Choose The Bigs if…
Buy The Bigs if you prefer higher review scores and broader console options.
Choose The Bigs 2 if…
Buy The Bigs 2 if you want the latest MLB rosters and newer release.
Common questions
Which game has the newer MLB rosters?
The Bigs 2 (2009) includes up‑to‑date 2009 rosters; The Bigs (2007) has older rosters.
What platforms can I play each on?
The Bigs is available on PS3, Xbox 360, and PS2; The Bigs 2 is noted for Wii motion controls only.
Do either games offer online multiplayer?
Both list only local multiplayer and split‑screen; neither mentions online multiplayer.