Tales of Monkey Island vs The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Embark on a swashbuckling journey with Guybrush Threepwood as he faces new foes, solves clever puzzles, and delivers the series' signature wit. This episodic adventure blends humor, clever dialogue, and challenging brain‑teasers across five chapters. Developed by Telltale Games and published by LucasArts, the game offers a single‑player experience on PlayStation 3, PC, iOS, and Mac, delivering the beloved Monkey Island charm to both longtime fans and newcomers.
The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition brings the beloved 1990 point-and-click adventure to modern platforms with hand‑painted graphics, fully voiced dialogue, and a revamped interface. Explore the Caribbean, meet quirky characters, and master the art of insult swordfighting as you search for the legendary treasure. This edition adds HD resolution, a hint system, and extra content like developer commentary, making it perfect for both nostalgic fans and newcomers looking for a witty, puzzle‑rich adventure.
- Engaging humor and witty writing
- Challenging yet fair puzzles
- Strong voice acting and character work
- Cross‑platform availability
- Beautifully remastered visuals
- Fully voiced dialogue adds immersion
- Hint system aids without hand‑holding
- Includes extra developer content
- Linear progression limits replayability
- Some puzzles can feel obtuse
- Graphics may feel dated to modern eyes
- Limited to single‑player experience
- Some puzzles can feel obtuse
- Controls may feel dated to newcomers
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Tales of Monkey Island
View all →
A witty pirate adventure that tests your puzzle‑solving wit
Witty pirate adventure where you outsmart ghosts and solve puzzles.
A witty pirate adventure that blends humor with classic point-and-click puzzles.
Sail, solve puzzles, and outwit pirates in a lovingly remastered classic adventure.
Alternatives to The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition
View all →A witty pirate adventure that tests your puzzle‑solving wit
Witty pirate adventure where you outsmart ghosts and solve puzzles.
Revisit the classic pirate adventure with updated graphics and voice acting
A witty pirate adventure that blends humor with classic point-and-click puzzles.
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataBoth games offer classic point‑and‑click Monkey Island adventures at the same price, but Tales of Monkey Island adds cross‑platform saves and episodic variety, while The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition delivers a fully remastered visual and audio experience.
Key differences
- •Tales of Monkey Island supports cross‑platform saves between PC and mobile; Special Edition does not.
- •Special Edition features high‑definition hand‑painted graphics; Tales uses hand‑drawn art with a more dated look.
- •Special Edition includes bonus developer commentary and an Insult Swordfighting tutorial; Tales does not.
- •Both have full voice acting, but Tales emphasizes dynamic inventory combos, whereas Special Edition focuses on streamlined UI.
- •Release dates are close (July 2009) but developed by different studios (Telltale vs. LucasArts).
Gameplay & fun factor
Tales adds dialogue choices affecting story flow and a dynamic inventory system, offering more interactive depth.
Platform availability
Tales supports cross‑platform saves between PC and mobile; Special Edition is limited to a single platform per purchase.
Price & value
Both cost $19.99 and share the same critic score (80/100), offering comparable monetary value.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Both are single‑player only; no multiplayer options for either.
Content & replayability
Special Edition includes extra developer commentary and a tutorial, adding supplemental content beyond the core game.
Difficulty & accessibility
Special Edition’s optional hint system and modernized UI make puzzles more accessible than Tales’ hint system.
Graphics & performance
Special Edition’s high‑definition, hand‑painted artwork is visually superior to Tales’ hand‑drawn, potentially dated graphics.
Choose Tales of Monkey Island if…
Players who want story choices, cross‑device continuity, and deeper inventory puzzles.
Choose The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition if…
Players who prioritize polished visuals, extra behind‑the‑scenes content, and a more beginner‑friendly interface.
Common questions
Do both games have full voice acting?
Yes, both feature fully voiced dialogue.
Can I continue my progress from PC to mobile?
Only Tales of Monkey Island supports cross‑platform saves.
Is there any extra content beyond the main adventure?
Special Edition includes developer commentary, behind‑the‑scenes videos, and an Insult Swordfighting tutorial; Tales does not.