Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective vs Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective is a classic FMV adventure where players join Holmes and Watson to investigate three murder cases. The game blends interactive storytelling with map exploration and newspaper archives to recreate Victorian London. The 1991 CD‑ROM release from ICOM Simulations brings the original book‑based experience to Mac, offering full‑motion video scenes and a deep detective simulation for a single‑player experience.
Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II lets players step into the shoes of the legendary detective and Dr. Watson to unravel three distinct, stand‑alone cases set in 1880s London. Each investigation blends narrative storytelling with point‑and‑click exploration, requiring careful note‑taking, clue gathering, and deduction to reach the correct solution. The game preserves the classic FMV style of the original series while delivering fresh puzzles and period‑accurate atmosphere. Designed for Mac, it offers a single‑player experience that challenges both newcomers and veteran mystery fans alike.
- Authentic FMV storytelling
- Rich, atmospheric Victorian setting
- Multiple cases increase replay value
- Deep investigative mechanics
- Rich, atmospheric Victorian setting
- Three distinct, well‑written cases
- Full‑motion video adds cinematic flair
- Deep clue‑tracking system
- Graphics are dated by modern standards
- Limited to Mac platform only
- No multiplayer or co‑op options
- Interface feels dated compared to modern adventure games
- Limited replay value after solving all cases
- Mac version may require compatibility tweaks on newer OS releases
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective
View all →Solve three gripping Victorian mysteries with Holmes and Watson.
Solve a Victorian murder in a classic point‑and‑click adventure.
Solve a murder mystery at the Mirapolis hotel with Conan and friends
Alternatives to Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II
View all →Solve a Victorian murder in a classic point‑and‑click adventure.
Solve Victorian mysteries in a sprawling 50‑location adventure.
Solve a murder mystery in Victorian London with Holmes and Watson
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataBoth games offer the same Victorian FMV detective experience on Mac, but the original title adds slightly more replay value.
Key differences
- •Price: A lists an MSRP of $49.99; B does not specify a price.
- •Replay value: A notes multiple cases increase replay value; B warns limited replay after solving all cases.
- •Publisher list: B includes additional publishers (Viacom New Media, Turbo Technologies, Victor Musical Industries) not mentioned for A.
Pricing & value
A provides a clear MSRP ($49.99); B's price is not specified, making A the only known‑cost option.
Gameplay & fun factor
Both feature three FMV‑driven cases, clue‑tracking notebooks, and Victorian maps; core gameplay is identical.
Platform availability
Both run natively on Mac only; no other platforms are mentioned.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Both are single‑player experiences with no multiplayer options.
Content & replayability
A emphasizes multiple cases increase replay value; B notes limited replay after solving all cases.
Graphics & performance
Both rely on dated FMV graphics; no performance differences are stated.
Choose Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective if…
Buyers who want a known price and slightly higher replay value.
Choose Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II if…
Buyers who are indifferent to price and accept limited replay after case completion.
Common questions
What is the cost of each game?
A lists an MSRP of $49.99; B does not provide a price in the supplied data.
Can I play either game on Windows or consoles?
Both are documented as Mac‑only; no other platforms are mentioned.
Which game offers more reason to replay after finishing the cases?
A mentions multiple cases increase replay value, whereas B states replay value is limited after solving all cases.