Kelly Slater's Pro Surfer vs Surf's Up
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Experience the thrill of surfing iconic breaks around the world in this action‑sport title. With high‑resolution 3‑D models of real surfers, you can perform signature tricks and chase barrels in both single‑player and split‑screen modes.
Based on the 2007 film, Surf's Up lets you control Cody Maverick, a young penguin surfer from Shiverpool Antarctica, as he enters the Big Z Memorial Surf Off on the island of Pen Gu. Play solo or with friends across a variety of colorful environments, from icy Shiverpool to volcanic coasts, mastering tricks and competing for the top spot. The game features ten playable characters and multiple competition modes, offering both single‑player challenges and multiplayer fun on PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, PC, and Mac. With its light‑hearted cartoon style and easy‑to‑learn controls, it’s perfect for gamers of all ages who love sports action.
- Authentic surfer models
- Intuitive control layout
- Variety of real‑world locations
- Local split‑screen multiplayer
- Easy to pick up controls
- Colorful cartoon visuals
- Variety of characters and locations
- Fun multiplayer modes
- Graphics dated by modern standards
- Limited online features
- Soundtrack could be more diverse
- Limited depth for hardcore gamers
- Repetitive wave patterns
- Online features are basic
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Kelly Slater's Pro Surfer
View all →
Ride massive waves and pull off pro surfer tricks in a thrilling surf simulator.
Alternatives to Surf's Up
View all →Ride massive waves and pull off pro surfer tricks in a thrilling surf simulator.
Ride massive waves with authentic 3‑D surfers and intuitive controls
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataKelly Slater's Pro Surfer offers a more authentic, surf‑focused experience with real‑world locations but is older and pricier; Surf's Up is cheaper, cartoon‑styled, and more family‑friendly with broader multiplayer options.
Key differences
- •Authenticity vs. cartoon style: Kelly Slater's uses real‑world spots and realistic wave physics; Surf's Up uses a whimsical penguin theme.
- •Price: Kelly Slater's MSRP $49.99; Surf's Up MSRP $29.99.
- •Multiplayer scope: Kelly Slater's only split‑screen (2 players); Surf's Up supports up to 4 players locally and online leaderboards.
- •Release era and graphics: Kelly Slater's released 2002 with dated graphics; Surf's Up released 2007 with more modern visuals.
- •Target audience: Kelly Slater's aims at surfing enthusiasts; Surf's Up targets casual/family gamers.
Gameplay & fun factor
Kelly Slater's provides realistic surf physics and career modes, appealing to surf fans seeking depth.
Platform availability
Both are console titles; specific platforms not listed, so availability appears equal.
Price & value
Surf's Up costs $29.99 versus Kelly Slater's $49.99, offering lower entry cost.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Surf's Up supports up to 4 local players and online leaderboards; Kelly Slater's only 2‑player split screen.
Content & replayability
Kelly Slater's includes multiple real‑world locations, career progression, time trials, and free surf sessions.
Difficulty & accessibility
Surf's Up features easy‑to‑pick‑up controls and cartoon visuals, making it more accessible for casual players.
Graphics & performance
Surf's Up (2007) likely has newer graphics than Kelly Slater's (2002), which is noted as dated.
Choose Kelly Slater's Pro Surfer if…
Surf enthusiasts who want realistic wave physics and career depth, and don’t need extensive multiplayer.
Choose Surf's Up if…
Casual or family gamers seeking affordable, easy‑to‑learn surf fun with up to four players.
Common questions
Which game is cheaper?
Surf's Up costs $29.99, while Kelly Slater's Pro Surfer costs $49.99.
Can I play with more than two friends?
Surf's Up supports up to four local players and online leaderboards; Kelly Slater's only supports two players split‑screen.
Which game offers a more realistic surfing experience?
Kelly Slater's Pro Surfer features real‑world locations and realistic wave physics, aimed at authentic surf simulation.