Dungeon Siege vs Secret of Mana
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Dungeon Siege is a third‑person action role‑playing game that drops players into a sprawling fantasy world filled with monsters, quests, and treasure. Its real‑time combat system lets you swing weapons and cast spells without pause, creating a fluid adventure experience. The game supports both single‑player and multiplayer modes, allowing friends to team up and tackle the game's challenges together. Originally released in 2002 for PC and later ported to Mac, it remains a classic for fans of action‑driven RPGs.
Secret of Mana is a timeless action role‑playing game that introduced the revolutionary Ring Command menu, letting players access items, weapons and magic instantly in real time. Set in a richly detailed fantasy world, you guide Randi, Primm and Popoi on a quest to restore the power of Mana while battling an empire and elemental forces.
- Fluid, uninterrupted combat
- Engaging co‑op multiplayer
- Rich loot variety
- Spacious, explorable world
- Innovative ring menu system
- Engaging real‑time combat
- Three‑player cooperative mode
- Timeless story and world
- Outdated graphics by modern standards
- Limited character customization compared to newer RPGs
- Multiplayer matchmaking can be unreliable
- Graphics show their age compared to modern titles
- Original save system was limited, affecting convenience
- Touch controls can feel less precise than a controller
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Dungeon Siege
View all →
Lead a squad of freelancers through a post-apocalyptic Sweden in this real-time dungeon crawler.
Alternatives to Secret of Mana
View all →
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataDungeon Siege offers a larger, modern‑era world with richer loot and four‑player co‑op at a higher price, while Secret of Mana delivers classic gameplay, a unique ring menu, and three‑player co‑op at a lower price but with older graphics.
Key differences
- •Co‑op capacity: Dungeon Siege supports up to 4 players; Secret of Mana supports up to 3.
- •Price: Dungeon Siege costs $49.99; Secret of Mana costs $19.99.
- •Content scope: Dungeon Siege has a large, interconnected world and procedural loot; Secret of Mana features an open‑world but less loot variety.
- •Critical reception: Secret of Mana has a higher critic score (88) than Dungeon Siege (72).
- •Release era: Dungeon Siege (2002) has newer engine but dated graphics; Secret of Mana (1993) is a classic with iconic ring menu.
Gameplay & fun factor
Dungeon Siege offers real‑time combat plus skill trees and extensive loot, providing deeper customization than Secret of Mana.
Platform availability
Secret of Mana is ported to Android, iOS, and Switch, while Dungeon Siege is only PC/Mac.
Price & value
Secret of Mana costs $19.99 versus $49.99 for Dungeon Siege, giving more value per dollar.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Dungeon Siege supports up to four players; Secret of Mana supports three.
Content & replayability
Procedurally generated loot and a larger world in Dungeon Siege boost replayability over Secret of Mana.
Difficulty & accessibility
Secret of Mana’s simpler controls and lower age rating (ESRB E10+) make it more accessible to younger players.
Graphics & performance
Both have outdated graphics, but Secret of Mana’s retro style is embraced, while Dungeon Siege’s graphics are noted as outdated by modern standards.
Choose Dungeon Siege if…
Players wanting a larger world, deeper loot, and up to 4‑player co‑op, and willing to pay more.
Choose Secret of Mana if…
Fans of classic RPGs who prefer lower cost, three‑player co‑op, and broader platform support.
Common questions
Which game is cheaper?
Secret of Mana costs $19.99; Dungeon Siege costs $49.99.
How many players can co‑op together?
Dungeon Siege supports up to four players; Secret of Mana supports up to three.
Is Secret of Mana available on modern consoles?
Yes, it is ported to Android, iOS, and Nintendo Switch.