Big Cartel vs Sellfy
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Big Cartel is an e-commerce platform built specifically for independent artists, musicians, jewelry makers, illustrators, and small creative businesses who want to sell online without dealing with complicated setup. Stores can be built from customizable templates with no coding required, and sellers can list physical goods, digital downloads, and print-on-demand products. Beyond the storefront, Big Cartel supports multi-channel selling through Instagram, Facebook, and Google Shopping, along with built-in analytics, inventory tracking, and marketing tools like discount codes and early access drops. The platform positions itself as a low-commitment alternative to larger e-commerce suites, with flexible monthly plans and no long-term contracts.
Sellfy is an ecommerce platform built for content creators and small businesses that want to launch an online store without coding. It supports selling digital downloads, physical products, print-on-demand merchandise, and recurring subscriptions from one storefront. The platform emphasizes zero transaction fees on sales and a drag-and-drop store builder, and reports more than 75,000 creators have collectively earned over $165 million through the platform.
- Purpose-built for artists and makers rather than generic retail
- Low monthly cost compared to larger e-commerce platforms
- No long-term contracts and easy plan cancellation
- Simple setup that does not require design or coding skills
- Zero transaction fees on sales within your plan's revenue threshold
- Combines digital, physical, print-on-demand, and subscription sales in one platform
- 14-day free trial with no credit card required
- Simple enough for creators without technical or design skills
- Fewer built-in apps and integrations than large platforms like Shopify
- Free plan is limited in product count and features
- Less suited to high-volume or complex B2B selling operations
- A 2% fee applies to sales that exceed your plan's revenue threshold unless you upgrade
- Less customizable design system than dedicated store builders like Shopify
- File size limits scale with plan tier, which can matter for large digital products
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Big Cartel
View all →
Alternatives to Sellfy
View all →
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataBig Cartel is the lower‑cost, artist‑focused store with basic multi‑channel tools, while Sellfy adds zero‑transaction fees up to a revenue cap and stronger digital/ subscription features.
Key differences
- •Big Cartel offers a free tier; Sellfy only paid plans (though with a free trial).
- •Sellfy has zero transaction fees within plan limits; Big Cartel charges standard processor fees.
- •Sellfy supports subscriptions and unlimited digital downloads; Big Cartel does not list subscription support.
- •Sellfy’s built‑in marketing (email campaigns, discount codes) is explicit; Big Cartel’s marketing tools are limited to abandoned cart recovery.
- •Sellfy provides PayPal, Stripe, and Printful integrations; Big Cartel integrates with Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace, Instagram, Facebook, Google Shopping, Zapier.
Pricing & value
Big Cartel has a freemium tier; Sellfy requires a paid subscription, though Sellfy waives transaction fees up to its revenue cap.
Ease of use / learning curve
Both are no‑code, drag‑and‑drop builders aimed at creators with no design or coding skills.
Features & depth
Sellfy includes subscriptions, zero‑fee tier, email marketing, and larger digital file handling; Big Cartel lacks these.
Integrations & ecosystem
Big Cartel connects to more storefront channels (Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace, Instagram, Facebook, Google Shopping, Zapier).
Support
Big Cartel offers priority human support on its Diamond plan; Sellfy only lists email and Help Center.
Scalability
Sellfy’s subscription and higher‑volume digital product handling suit growing creators; Big Cartel is noted as less suited for high‑volume or complex B2B.
Choose Big Cartel if…
Independent artists or makers needing a low‑cost, simple storefront with multi‑channel sync and no long‑term contract.
Choose Sellfy if…
Creators selling digital, print‑on‑demand, or subscription products who want zero transaction fees up to a revenue limit and built‑in marketing tools.
Common questions
Can I start for free?
Big Cartel offers a free plan with limited products; Sellfy only provides a 14‑day free trial, then requires a paid subscription.
Do I pay transaction fees on sales?
Sellfy charges no transaction fees within each plan’s revenue threshold; beyond that a 2% fee applies. Big Cartel does not list its own transaction fees, but standard processor fees still apply.
Which platform supports subscriptions?
Sellfy explicitly supports subscription products for recurring billing; Big Cartel does not list subscription functionality.